By Dominic Naimool, Synomos
Introduction
Budget 2026 proposes transferring AML/ATF supervision of federally regulated financial institutions from FINTRAC to OSFI. Finance says the change will deliver stronger, more integrated supervision under a single regulator, and that it is not tied to any report or enforcement matter. It does follow a recent Auditor General report finding delays in FINTRAC’s production of financial intelligence and a supervisory population too large to monitor effectively. It also follows a FATF finding that FINTRAC’s examinations of some sectors were not sufficiently frequent or commensurate with risk.
None of that criticism concerned credit unions in particular. But the remedy leaves them in a different position from the institutions it targets. Provincially regulated credit unions remain under FINTRAC for AML/ATF compliance under the PCMLTFA, while prudential supervision stays with provincial regulators such as FSRA. Federal institutions will have one supervisor. Credit unions will have two.
What the Proposal Does and Does Not Do
The transfer addresses a documented problem at the large end of the system. It does not address the underlying strain on FINTRAC, which will continue to supervise a population of roughly 38,000 businesses, including every provincially regulated credit union. Nor does the proposal say what happens to FINTRAC’s resources, funding model or guidance once its largest supervised institutions move. Those details will determine what the change means for credit unions, and none has been announced.
Four Issues for the Sector
Capacity: Supervisory expertise is finite. If experienced examiners move to OSFI, FINTRAC’s remaining capacity will matter directly to credit unions. The Auditor General has already identified capacity as the problem.
Cost: If FINTRAC’s mandate narrows, its funding needs do not necessarily narrow with it. Credit unions should ask whether fees, assessments or indirect compliance costs will fall more heavily on the entities that remain.
Consistency: AML/ATF compliance runs on administrative guidance, and FINTRAC’s guidance is what reporting entities rely on to operationalize the PCMLTFA. OSFI has largely moved to principles-based prudential supervision and, as FATF has noted, does not conduct hands-on AML examinations today. How it approaches this new division of responsibilities is untested. If OSFI and FINTRAC develop different practical expectations, institutions bound by the same statute will be measured by different standards. As one regulatory lawyer told The Globe and Mail, consistency between the two supervisors will matter.
Proportionality: A three-branch credit union and a systemically important bank carry the same statutory obligations. They do not carry the same risk profile or resources. A supervisory model built around the largest institutions needs deliberate adjustment to fit smaller ones.
The Options
There are three broad paths, and none is costless.
Responsibility Transfers to FSRA
This would move credit unions toward the integrated model proposed for banks, with one supervisor for prudential and AML/ATF matters. The appeal is real. A regulator that already examines governance, enterprise risk management and internal controls is well placed to assess how AML/ATF compliance fits within them.
The difficulties are also real. The PCMLTFA assigns compliance supervision to FINTRAC, so any shift would require federal legislative or regulatory change. Credit unions operate under provincial regimes across the country, and a provincially delivered model risks a patchwork of approaches to a single federal statute. FSRA would also need the capacity and mandate to do the work.
Responsibility Stays with FINTRAC
This keeps the current division and presses for structural safeguards: a formal coordination framework among FINTRAC, OSFI and provincial regulators, a commitment to common interpretive guidance, transparency on funding, and an express proportionality standard in examination practice. It preserves FINTRAC’s role as both supervisor and financial intelligence unit and avoids new fragmentation.
Its weakness is that it relies on administrative commitments, which are easier to give than to enforce. It also leaves credit unions with two supervisors while banks have one.
Responsibility Switches to OSFI
This would extend the proposed federal model to credit unions, giving the whole deposit-taking sector a single AML/ATF supervisor and consistent expectations. It would also draw on OSFI’s institutional experience supervising financial institutions.
The Budget does not contemplate it, and it would require federal change. OSFI is a prudential regulator with no existing supervisory relationship with provincially regulated credit unions. It would also separate AML supervision from prudential supervision for credit unions, the opposite of the integration the proposal is meant to achieve. And its approach to AML examinations is untested.
None of the three can be dismissed. Each should be evaluated on evidence, not assumed.
What Counsel and Boards Can Do Now
Monitor the implementing legislation and any Finance consultation, and take part in it.
Raise these questions through trade associations, which are the more effective channel for sector-wide advocacy.
Document the actual cost and effort of AML/ATF compliance so the sector can speak with data.
Brief boards. AML/ATF supervision is a governance matter, and directors should understand that the supervisory landscape may change.
Risks to Consider
These are risks the sector should weigh, not predictions. Several depend on details the Budget has not yet announced.
Loss of deposit-taking expertise and attention: Expertise is finite. If expertise, along with policy attention and resources, moves to OSFI, credit unions become a small remainder within a regulator that no longer specializes in their sector. FINTRAC’s guidance may also lose the visibility into large-institution practice that has informed it.
Access to talent: If credit unions are the principal deposit-taking institutions left under FINTRAC, the market for AML/ATF professionals may orient itself around the OSFI model. Credit unions, which already recruit from a limited pool, may struggle to find and keep people fluent in FINTRAC’s expectations, and may hire staff trained for a different supervisory approach.
Who publishes and who interprets the guidance: AML/ATF compliance is heavily guideline-driven, and FINTRAC has published and refined that guidance for some time. If OSFI takes over supervision of federal institutions, who will publish guidance, who will interpret it, and how will consistency be ensured across FINTRAC, OSFI and provincial regulators? Without answers, institutions bound by the same statute could face different practical standards.
Asymmetric enforcement models: FINTRAC enforces through administrative monetary penalties, which it publishes. Prudential supervisors have historically relied more on supervisory dialogue. Similar deficiencies could be handled in a more public, penalty-driven way for credit unions than for banks.
Structural lock-in: Once a two-tier structure is in legislation, it will be difficult to reverse. Design decisions made before credit unions are heard may define the sector’s position for years.
Conclusion
The Budget fixes a real problem at the top of the system. It should not create a new one at the other end of it. Whichever path the legislature takes, credit unions need a seat at the table before the structure is set, because a two-tier model written into legislation will be hard to undo.
The Sector’s Ask: The sector should ask now for a formal coordination framework among FINTRAC, OSFI and provincial regulators, one set of interpretive guidance, and an express proportionality standard for smaller institutions.

Dominic Naimool
Dominic Naimool is a Barrister and Solicitor and the principal of Synomos Law.
This article is general commentary for information purposes only. It is not legal advice and does not create a solicitor-client relationship. The views expressed are my own and do not represent those of Kingston Community Credit Union or any other organization. Budget 2026 measures are proposals and may change.